The classification of mitochondrial diseases reflects
the peculiar feature of the oxidative phosphorylation system of being formed by
proteins encoded by two different genomes: mtDNA and nuclear genome.
The first group of illnesses is characterized by the
presence of mutations in mtDNA, that can be transmitted either maternally or
sporadic. A second group of disorders is caused by mutations in nuclear genes
that make up or control oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Since many
OXPHOS-related nuclear genes are still unknown in humans, several of these
illnesses are classified only on the basis of biochemical alterations, revealed
by the analysis of affected tissue (especially skeletal muscle). The high
clinical, biochemical and molecular heterogeneity of these disorders explains
why only about 50% of the patients with a clinical/biochemical defined
mitochondrial disease have a genetic diagnosis.
The recent technological advances in the field of
next-generation DNA sequencing (NGS) offer an affordable and highly informative
tool for the rapid and cost-effective analysis of a large number of DNA
sequences at the same time. This approach has led to the identification of
several nuclear genes associated with mitochondrial diseases and to an improvement
in the diagnostic process.
1. MtDNA Mutations
This group includes syndromes caused by either mtDNA
point mutations, large-scale rearrangements of mtDNA or reduction in the mtDNA
amount.
1.1 Point mutations
These are clinical entities associated with the
substitution of single bases or micro-insertions/micro-deletions in the mtDNA
molecule. These mutations may concern genes encoding transfer RNAs (tRNA),
ribosomal RNAs, (rRNA), or messenger RNAs (mRNA) that are then translated into
proteins. Almost all mtDNA point mutations are maternally transmitted. They are
often, but not always, heteroplasmic. Even if more than 100 point mutations
have been described in association with an extremely heterogeneous spectrum of
clinical presentations, only a few of them are frequent and associated with
well-defined clinical syndromes.
Leber's Hereditary Optic Neuropathy (
LHON,
OMIM535000) is a juvenile-onset condition affecting mostly males. It is
characterized by acute or sub-acute loss of central vision due to rapidly
progressive optic atrophy. This partial or complete (and usually permanent)
loss of vision is the only consistent manifestation of the disease which, more
rarely, may also include alterations in cardiac rhythm (ventricular
pre-excitation syndrome). The muscle biopsy does not show evidence of
ragged-red fibers and is not necessary for the diagnosis of the disease. This
disease is associated with mutations in the nucleotide positions m.3460, 11778,
or 14484 of mtDNA, in the gene encoding subunits ND1, ND4, and ND6 of complex
I, respectively. Other mutations, all present in complex I mtDNA genes, have
recently been identified. Many features of LHON remain to be clarified,
including the extreme tissue specificity of the anatomical and clinical lesion,
the prevalence among males, and the biochemical consequences of each mutation.
Neurogenic muscle weakness, ataxia, retinitis pigmentosa
(
NARP, OMIM551500) can also include, besides the above-mentioned
symptoms, epilepsy, and sometimes mental deterioration. Symptoms usually appear
in adulthood. Ragged-red fibers are absent in the muscle biopsy. The disease is
associated with mutation m. 8993T>G in the gene encoding subunit 6 of
mitochondrial ATPase (complex V of the respiratory chain). In patients
presenting a less serious NARP phenotype, a transition T->C in the same
position has also been described. The same m. 8993T>G mutation when present
in >90% of total mitochondrial genomes, leads to the more severe, earlier
onset
Leigh syndrome (MILS, maternally inherited Leigh syndrome).
Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathy, Lactic Acidosis, and
Stroke-like episodes, (
MELAS, OMIM540000) is defined by the following
symptoms: 1) stroke-like episodes caused by focal cerebral lesions, often
localized in the parieto-occipital regions of the brain; 2) lactic acidosis or
abnormal lactic levels in the blood (and cerebro-spinal fluid, CSF); 3)
"ragged-red" fibers in the muscle biopsy. Other signs involving the
central nervous system include mental deterioration, recurrent migraine with
"cerebral" vomiting, focal or generalized epilepsy and neurosensory
deafness. The disease is transmitted maternally and the onset varies from early
childhood to young adulthood. MELAS syndrome is typically associated with
mutation m.3243A>G in the gene encoding tRNA-Leu(UUR). Other point mutations
associated with MELAS have been reported, although they are much rarer than the
m.3243A>G.
Myoclonus Epilepsy with Ragged-Red Fibers, (
MERRF,
OMIM545000) is characterized by the association of myoclonus, epilepsy, muscle
weakness and wasting, motor incoordination (ataxia) and sometimes, mental
deterioration. Clinical manifestations can vary greatly even within the same
family. This variation is attributed to the quantity of mutated mtDNA in
relation to normal mtDNA (heteroplasmy) and to variation in the tissue
distribution of the mutation. The major part of affected families carry an
m.8344A>G transition in the gene encoding tRNA-Lys.
Numerous other point mutations of mtDNA have been
associated with different clinical phenotypes in single patients or in a few
families.
1.2 Qualitative alterations of mtDNA
These can be either partial deletions of mtDNA or less
frequently, partial duplications. Both types are heteroplasmic since they
co-exist with normal mtDNA. These coarse mtDNA alterations are almost
invariably associated with 3 main clinical presentations: Kearns-Sayre
Syndrome, Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia and Pearson's Syndrome.
Kearns-Sayre Syndrome is
a serious illness that occurs sporadically, and includes the triad of (1)
Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia (PEO) with bilateral drooping eyelids
(ptosis), (2) Pigmentary Retinopathy, and (3) onset before twenty years of age.
Other frequent signs are poor growth, motor incoordination (ataxia) due to
cerebellar failure, mental deterioration, deafness, and alterations of cardiac
rhythm (Atrio-ventricular blocks) often requiring the application of a
pace-maker.
Pearson's Syndrome is a
rare sporadic disease affecting newborn or very young babies. It is
characterized by sideroblastic anemia, pancytopenia and failure of exocrine
pancreas with intestinal malabsorption. A progressive improvement in the
hematologic and gastro-intestinal situation takes place in children who survive
the first years, but they usually develop a typical Kearns-Sayre Syndrome
afterwards.
Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia (
PEO) also
occurs sporadically and is characterized by the appearance of bi-lateral ptosis
and paralysis of eye-movement, often associated with weakness in girdle muscles
of the shoulders and pelvis. It appears in adulthood. PEO is often associated
with mtDNA multiple deletions. Mutations in diverse nuclear genes have been
associated with autosomal dominant or recessive PEO (see above “
Mitochondriopathy
due to mutations in nuclear genes”).
1.3 Quantitative alterations of mtDNA
A reduction of the amount of mtDNA is called
"depletion". Usually these forms are infantile with a progressive
course. The most involved organs are: skeletal muscle and heart, liver and
brain. Depletions of the mtDNA are caused by mutations in the nuclear genes
(see above "
Mitochondriopathy due to mutations in nuclear genes").
2. Mitochondriopathy due to mutations in nuclear genes
Over 90% of mitochondrial proteins are expressions of nuclear genes and include
the majority of the components of the OXPHOS system, proteins necessary for the
assembly of the respiratory chain complexes. Moreover mtDNA replication,
transcription and translation are dependent on nuclear encoded-proteins. A
growing number of degenerative hereditary diseases, especially in the
neurological field, have been linked to mutations in genes encoding proteins
that enter the mitochondrion and are more or less directly correlated to
OXPHOS.
The following is a brief outline of only one disease,
Leigh's
Syndrome, the most common and well-known of the group of diseases that
result from abnormalities in nuclear genes related to mitochondrial OXPHOS
(although, as reported in the paragraph 1.1 in about 20% of cases there are
mutations in the ATPase 6 gene and occasionally also point mutations in mtDNA
genes encoding COX subunits or tRNAs). After an initial period of normal
development in the first months of infancy, affected children present a
progressive delay in psychomotor development, accompanied by incoordination of
eye movements, recurrent vomiting, epilepsy, abnormalities in breathing rate,
and lactic acidosis. These symptoms can be referred to symmetric lesions of
neurological structures that originate, cross through, or are localized in the
basal ganglia, brainstem and cerebellum.
The frequent increase in lactic acid levels in blood and CSF suggests an
alteration in mitochondria energy metabolism. In more than half the cases it is
possible to document a genetic alteration. In about 30% of the cases the
biochemical defect is a profound decrease in the activity of Complex IV
activity (cytochrome c oxidase, COX) and the genetic alteration is due, in most
cases, to mutations in an assembly gene of complex IV, called SURF1. In other
cases, the biochemical defect is found in Complex I or Complex II of the
respiratory chain. Mutations in the subunits of these complexes have been
identified in some patients. Finally, in 10% of the cases a deficiency in
Pyruvate Dehydrogenase is detected, usually associated with mutations in the
X-linked gene encoding subunit E1-alpha of the enzyme.
A grouping of the corresponding proteins based on their
biological role among:
can be used for the classification of mitochondrial
disorders due to mutations in nuclear genes.
There are some proteins, not included in this
classification but indirectly correlated to OXPHOS, whose mutations cause
mitochondriopathies: e.g. proteins necessary for protein import into
mitochondria (TIMM8A, DNAJC19), proteins linked to apoptosis (AIFM1), and
proteins with a detoxifying role (ETHE1). All these conditions are extremely
rare.
2.1 Disorders due to defects in nuclear gene encoding structural
components of the OXPHOS complexes
Although 72 of the 85 subunits of the OXPHOS system are
encoded by nuclear DNA, mutations of these genes have only rarely been
described. This could imply that such mutations are highly deleterious and
probably embryo-lethal. Mutations that have been described in fact are usually
associated to a neonatal or early-onset, although occasional patients with a
late onset of disease have been reported. On the other hand the screening of
the nuclear-encoded subunits of respiratory chain has not always been done in a
systematic manner, especially for complex I. Thanks to the introduction of NGS
technologies, the number of reports regarding mutations in structural OXPHOS
component is grown up. The mutations in nuclear encoded subunits identified so
far, are mainly abnormalities of complex I found in patients with- infancy or
childhood-onset, even if also mutations in structural subunits of complex II,
III, IV and V were described. Typical phenotypic presentations are: Leigh
syndrome, leukoencephalopathy and cardio-myopathy.
2.2 Respiratory chain complex assembly deficiencies
OXPHOS complexes are multiheteromeric structure and for
their proper assembly several different factors are required; mutations
affecting these factors lead to formation of instable or partly functioning
complexes. For complexes III, IV and V, genetic alterations in genes belonging
to this group are more frequent that the mutations affecting structural
subunits, reported in the previous paragraph. The main clinical presentations
are the same, with various kinds of encephalomyopathies.
2.3 Disorders due to gene defects altering the mtDNA
maintenance
MtDNA remains dependent upon nuclear genome for the
production of proteins involved in its replication, transcription, translation,
repair and maintenance.
Replication of mtDNA requires a small set of proteins:
i.e. the DNA polymerase gamma (POLG), Twinkle helicase (PEO1), mitochondrial
single-stranded DNA binding protein (mtSSB), and a supply of deoxy-nucleotides
triphosphate (dNTPs). Structural defects of the DNA-processive enzymes are
often associated with mtDNA mutagenesis and multiple mtDNA deletions
(qualitative alterations; see paragraph 1.2), whereas defects affecting the
dNTP pool usually cause mtDNA depletion, that mean reduction of mtDNA copy
number/cell (quantitative alterations; see paragraph 1.3).
Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia and muscle weakness
are typical of genes causing mtDNA qualitative alterations while genes
associated with quantitative alterations (mtDNA depletions) cause different
disorders with neurological, muscular or hepatic involvement.
Mitochondrial DNA translation or protein synthesis is
carried out in the mitochondrial matrix by a machinery, which is composed of
tRNAs and rRNAs synthesized in situ from the corresponding mitochondrial genes
and a number of proteins encoded by nuclear DNA and imported into mitochondria.
Different mutations affecting subunits of mitochondrial ribosomes, enzymes with
a role in mitochondrial tRNA maturation, elongation factors, amino acyl tRNA
synthetases have been found in patients with mitochondrial diseases and
clinically constitute one of the most heterogeneous groups.
2.4 Defects of genes encoding factors involved in the
biosynthesis of cofactors
CoQ or ubiquinone is a lipophilic component of the
electron-transport chain, which transfers electrons from Complex I or II, and
from the oxidation of fatty acids and branched-chain amino acids, to Complex
III. The CoQ also plays a role as an antioxidant and as a membrane stabilizer.
Mutations in genes encoding enzymes responsible for the CoQ biosynthesis are
usually associated with CoQ10 deficiency in muscle and cause myoglobinuria
and/or early-onset ataxia.
All components of the respiratory chain are embedded in
the lipid milieu of the inner mitochondrial membrane, which is composed
predominantly of cardiolipin. Cardiolipin is not merely a scaffold but is
essential for proper functioning of several mitochondrial OXPHOS complexes and
several mitochondrial carrier proteins. This is the reason why defects in
cardiolipin could cause OXPHOS dysfunction and hence mitochondrial disease. In
fact there is an example on this regard, the
Barth syndrome
(mitochondrial myopathy, cardiomyopathy, growth retardation, and leukopenia),
caused by mutation in the gene
TAZ o tafazzin.
The OXPHOS complexes need to be equipped with cofactors
such as copper, heme or iron-sulphur (FeS) clusters that are necessary for
their electron transport capacity. A whole range of complex-specific
chaperones, assembly factors and enzymes involved in the biosynthesis and
incorporation of prosthetic groups are necessary for the assembly of intact and
enzymatically functional complexes. The clinical spectrum associated with these
impairments is broad: myopathy, leukoencephalopathy, sideroblastic anemia…
2.5 Defects of proteins involved in mitochondrial
biogenesis/dynamics
Mitochondria are not static and isolated organelles but
form a complex network. Mitochondrial fusion and fission require conserved
protein machineries at the outer and inner membranes that mediate membrane
mixing and division events.
The primary protein for the regulation of inner membrane
morphology is OPA1, mutations of which cause optic atrophy. Neuropathies,
Charcot-Marie-Tooth type, are instead associated with mutations in MFN2, fusion
protein of the outer membrane, while mutation in genes encoding mitochondrial
fission factors (DNM1L, MFF) are usually responsible for severe, early-onset
encephalopathies.